The Finger Lakes region offers a unique shopping experience filled with local charm and specialty items. Whether you’re searching for handmade crafts, local goods, or memorable souvenirs, the area has many options that highlight the craftsmanship and culture of the region.

I’ve identified five gift shops in the Finger Lakes that stand out for their quality, variety, and local appeal. These shops provide a great way to find something meaningful, whether for yourself or as a gift for others. Exploring them offers a chance to connect with the community and discover authentic Finger Lakes products.

Check my article on what to buy in Finger Lakes!

1) Finger Lakes Goods

When I visited Finger Lakes Goods, I found a charming gift shop that captures the spirit of the Finger Lakes region. The store offers a thoughtful selection of items, including apparel with local designs and unique gift products. Their t-shirts, tanks, and accessories show clear regional pride, making them perfect souvenirs or gifts.

I was also drawn to their selection of specialty snacks like wine gummies and locally sourced treats. These add a nice touch for anyone looking to bring home authentic Finger Lakes flavors. The store’s range includes not only gifts but also wine-related products and corporate gifts.

The atmosphere was inviting, and the staff were helpful, happy to share details about the items and the region. This mix of local character and quality products makes Finger Lakes Goods stand out as a go-to spot for visitors in Geneva.

Rating: 4.8 (35 reviews)
Location: 40 Linden St, Geneva, NY 14456
Contact: (315) 256-0312
Website: Visit Website

2) Finger Lakes Unique

When I visited Finger Lakes Unique, I found a well-curated gift shop filled with locally crafted items that capture the region’s spirit. The shop has a welcoming atmosphere with a variety of handmade products that make thoughtful gifts or souvenirs.

The store layout made it easy to browse, and the variety ensured there was something for every taste. I appreciated the small, creative details in many of the items, which reflect the area’s artisan culture. The staff was friendly and happy to share insights about their products.

Their hours are convenient, especially if you’re planning a weekend visit. I noticed it stays open late on most days, which is helpful for flexible travel plans. Overall, it’s a solid stop for anyone looking to take home a unique piece of local craftsmanship.

Rating: 4.8 (46 reviews)
Location: 99 E Market St, Corning, NY 14830
Contact: (607) 377-6505
Website: Visit Website

3) Watkins Glen State Park Gift Shop

When I visited Watkins Glen State Park, I made sure to stop by the gift shop located near the main entrance. It offers a nice selection of souvenirs that reflect the natural beauty of the park and the Finger Lakes region. The staff were helpful and familiar with the local area, which made finding unique gifts easy.

The shop is open from mid-May through the end of November, so timing your visit is important if you want to stop by. It carries a variety of items like apparel, local crafts, and park memorabilia. I found the quality to be consistent with what you’d expect at a well-maintained state park store.

Since the park itself is quite popular for hiking, camping, and sightseeing, the gift shop serves as a convenient spot to pick up supplies or keepsakes. It’s also a good place to ask questions about park activities, trail conditions, and other amenities during the changing seasons.

Rating: 4.4 (501 reviews)
Location: 1001 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891
Contact: (607) 535-4022
Website: Visit Website

4) The Nest Egg

I visited The Nest Egg during a trip to Penn Yan, and it stood out as a charming spot for unique gifts. The shop is well-organized, making it easy to browse through a variety of carefully selected items. I found a mix of local crafts and stylish home accessories that felt thoughtfully curated.

The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, offering helpful suggestions without being pushy. The atmosphere felt cozy and inviting, which made spending time there enjoyable. It’s the kind of place where you can find something for different occasions or just treat yourself.

The Nest Egg’s location on Main Street makes it convenient to visit if you are exploring the downtown area. They also maintain an active social media presence, which helps to keep customers informed about new arrivals and special events.

Rating: 4.7 (49 reviews)
Location: 125 Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Contact: (315) 536-3488
Website: Visit Website

5) Browsers

I found Browsers in Hammondsport to be a charming spot for unique gifts and souvenirs. The store offers a wide selection of clothing and local items that feel thoughtfully curated. It’s small but welcoming, perfect for finding something out of the ordinary.

The staff were friendly and helpful when I visited, making the shopping experience smooth and pleasant. Browsers has a cozy atmosphere that makes it easy to browse without feeling rushed. I appreciated the mix of practical gifts and artistic pieces.

The location on Shethar Street is easy to find and convenient to other local attractions. It’s a good stop if you want to pick up something special to remember your trip or to give as a gift.

Rating: 4.7 (36 reviews)
Location: 33 Shethar St, Hammondsport, NY 14840
Contact: (607) 569-2497

What Makes Finger Lakes Gift Shops Unique?

Finger Lakes gift shops stand out for their strong connection to the local culture and economy. They offer authentic and meaningful products that reflect the region’s natural beauty and artisan traditions. The range of goods also includes well-known regional specialties that serve as lasting memories of your visit.

Local Artisans and Handcrafted Goods

Many gift shops in the Finger Lakes feature products made by local artisans. These include handcrafted jewelry, glasswork, pottery, and textiles. When I browse these shops, I notice a focus on quality and originality that mass-produced items can’t match.

Some shops even let you see artists at work or participate in making your own piece, like the Hands-on Glass Studio. This hands-on element deepens the value of the gift since it becomes personalized and unique.

Regional Specialties and Finger Lakes Souvenirs

The region is famous for its wines, especially Riesling, and many shops offer bottles sourced directly from local vineyards. I also find specialty foods like Naples grape pie and pure maple syrup, which are distinctive Finger Lakes treats.

Souvenirs often highlight the natural scenery or cultural history, from handcrafted decor to locally themed goods. These products provide tangible connections to a Finger Lakes visit, combining both practicality and local significance.

Tips for Shopping in the Finger Lakes Region

When I shop in the Finger Lakes, I focus on timing my visits and choosing shops that support local artisans. These practices enhance the experience and help me find meaningful, unique gifts. I also pay attention to the seasonal rhythms of the region and the importance of small business owners to the local economy.

Best Times to Visit Gift Shops

I prefer to visit gift shops during weekdays, especially in the mornings. This timing helps me avoid crowds and gives me more time to explore products carefully.

Spring and fall, outside of major holidays, are particularly good times. The region is less busy, and new seasonal items are often available.

During the holiday season, some shops offer special events or extended hours, but it can get crowded. Planning ahead and arriving early is key.

Supporting Small Businesses

I always prioritize shops that feature local artisans and handcrafted items. These businesses make a significant impact on the Finger Lakes economy.

Buying from boutique stores or specialty shops helps preserve regional culture and supports independent craftspeople.

Gift shops that sell locally made wines, foods, and art not only offer quality products but also share the story of the Finger Lakes.

I look for shops that clearly highlight their local partnerships and avoid large chain stores when possible. This way, my purchase has more value to the community.

Let me know in the comments if you have any other top “what to buy” ideas!

About the Author 

Colin is the founder of SouvenirsIdeas.com and a passionate traveller with a soft spot for ceramics, markets, and food tours. He writes practical, first-hand guides to help you bring home souvenirs that actually mean something — not just more clutter!