Salt air, clapboard porches, and the clack of ferry ropes — Martha’s Vineyard arrives like a memory you want to keep. Morning fog lifts off Menemsha Harbor and the Gay Head cliffs glow red; gingerbread cottages in Oak Bluffs hum with porch chatter while sailboats drift in Edgartown Harbor.

If you’re hunting for souvenirs from Martha’s Vineyard, look for pieces that smell of sea spray, hold a story, and fit easily into your suitcase.

Here’s what to buy in Martha’s Vineyard to bring a piece of the island home with you. I’ve listed my top 5 gift shops here

1. ChappyWrap blanket scarves

Why pick this up: These oversized, wool-blend wraps are island staples — cozy, colorful and built for blustery ferry rides and chilly sunset walks. They feel like a wearable souvenir that immediately recalls Vineyard evenings.
What to look for: Heavier wool blends for warmth, the signature plaid and stripe patterns, and limited-edition seasonal colors sold only in island shops.
Price bracket (2025): $60–$180
Where to find it: ChappyWrap boutiques and island boutiques in Oak Bluffs and Edgartown, plus seasonal pop-ups on Circuit Avenue.

2. Vineyard Vines polo or hat

Why pick this up: Founded on the Vineyard, Vineyard Vines’ cheerful whale logo has become shorthand for New England summer. A polo or cap is both practical and a classic memento.
What to look for: Island-exclusive colors or embroidered town names (Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven) and heavier summer-weight fabrics.
Price bracket (2025): $40–$150
Where to find it: Vineyard Vines stores and clothing shops along Circuit Avenue in Oak Bluffs and among Edgartown’s boutiques.

3. Sea glass jewelry

Why pick this up: Smooth, frosted sea glass captures the island’s beaches in miniature — a piece of the shoreline you can wear every day.
What to look for: Genuine beach-found glass set in sterling silver or gold vermeil, or pieces mounted by local jewelers who can confirm their beach provenance.
Price bracket (2025): $25–$200
Where to find it: Menemsha and Edgartown galleries, Oak Bluffs boardwalk artisans, and boutiques on Main Street.

4. Wampanoag pottery & quahog-shell crafts

Why pick this up: Aquinnah’s Wampanoag heritage is woven into the island — clay, quahog shells and traditional designs make for meaningful keepsakes that honor local culture.
What to look for: Pieces made by Wampanoag artisans (look for artist attribution), handmade clay mugs or tiles using local Gay Head clay, and quahog shell jewelry or wampum-inspired beads.
Price bracket (2025): $30–$250
Where to find it: Aquinnah shops, the Aquinnah Cultural Center, and select galleries that feature tribal artists.

5. Martha’s Vineyard sea salt

Why pick this up: A jar of island-harvested sea salt is small, easy to pack, and tastes like the ocean — perfect for giving your kitchen a Vineyard finish.
What to look for: Small-batch, hand-harvested sea salt or flavored salts (smoked, herb-infused) in sealed jars.
Price bracket (2025): $8–$20
Where to find it: Farmers’ markets (West Tisbury), Edgartown general stores, and specialty food shops in Vineyard Haven.

6. Wild blueberry jam and preserves

Why pick this up: The island’s wild blueberries make intensely flavored jams and preserves — spread on toast they’re an instant ferry-morning memory.
What to look for: Small-batch or foraged-wild blueberry varieties, or mixed preserves like blueberry-lavender or blueberry-maple.
Price bracket (2025): $6–$18
Where to find it: West Tisbury Farmers’ Market, Morning Glory Farm, and gift shops in Chilmark and Edgartown.

7. Menemsha smoked fish

Why pick this up: Menemsha’s fishermen still smoke fish the old way — a package of smoked striped bass or mackerel is a savory, undeniably island-flavored souvenir.
What to look for: Vacuum-sealed packages labeled with catch type and smoking method; ask about best-before dates for travel.
Price bracket (2025): $8–$35
Where to find it: Menemsha Fish Market and seafood stalls in the harbor villages.

8. Saltwater taffy and Ben & Bill’s fudge

Why pick this up: Old-fashioned sweets are a small, joyful reminder of Nantucket-style seaside candy counters and boardwalk strolls.
What to look for: Freshly made saltwater taffy, seasonal flavors, and fudge made in small batches or sold in gift boxes.
Price bracket (2025): $4–$20
Where to find it: Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium in Oak Bluffs, Edgartown candy shops, and bakeries along Circuit Avenue.

9. Local art and lighthouse prints

Why pick this up: A watercolour or photographic print of Gay Head cliffs, the Edgartown Lighthouse, or a Menemsha sunset captures the island’s dramatic light and makes a beautiful wall piece.
What to look for: Signed prints or limited editions by Vineyard photographers and painters, framing options offered on-island.
Price bracket (2025): $20–$500
Where to find it: Edgartown galleries, Oak Bluffs artists’ co-ops, the Martha’s Vineyard Museum gift shop, and summer art fairs.

10. Handwoven baskets and seagrass market totes

Why pick this up: Sturdy, coastal-woven baskets are practical and decorative — perfect for picnics, farmers’ market runs, or home display.
What to look for: Handwoven seagrass or wicker, solid handles, and makers’ tags from island artisans; look for weather-treated finishes for longevity.
Price bracket (2025): $40–$300
Where to find it: West Tisbury craft fairs, Edgartown artisan shops, and seasonal markets across the island.

Tip: For authentic souvenirs from Martha’s Vineyard, time your shopping to hit the West Tisbury Farmers’ Market and island craft fairs, and don’t miss Aquinnah’s artisan stalls for Wampanoag-made goods. 🌊

Let me know in the comments if you have any other top ‘what to buy’ ideas!

About the Author

Colin is the founder of SouvenirsIdeas.com and a passionate traveller with a soft spot for ceramics, markets, and food tours. He writes practical, first-hand guides to help you bring home souvenirs that actually mean something — not just more clutter!