Cape May offers a variety of gift shops that cater to different tastes and interests, making it a great destination for finding unique presents and souvenirs. Whether you’re looking for handcrafted jewelry, local specialties, or charming home decor, there are plenty of options to explore.

The best gift shops in Cape May provide thoughtfully curated selections that reflect the character and charm of the area. I’ve gathered five standout spots that offer quality products and memorable shopping experiences. These shops are a convenient stop for visitors and locals looking to bring home something special.

1) Sunset Beach

I visited Sunset Beach and found it to be a unique spot combining history and natural beauty. The beach is known for the submerged remains of the SS Atlantus, a concrete ship that adds an unusual visual element to the shoreline.

Walking along the sand, I noticed quartz crystals scattered, which adds a small treasure hunt aspect to the visit. The sunsets here are truly colorful and create a calm atmosphere perfect for relaxing.

The place also features a gift shop where you can find local souvenirs related to the beach and its history. It’s a practical stop if you want to take a piece of Cape May home with you.

The setting is peaceful, and even though it’s popular with tourists, the beach doesn’t feel overcrowded. It’s ideal for those who appreciate natural scenery along with a bit of historical intrigue.

Rating: 4.8 (6126 reviews)
Location: 502 Sunset Blvd, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-7079
Website: Visit Website

2) Whale’s Tale

I found Whale’s Tale to be a charming gift shop with a broad selection that goes beyond typical souvenirs. The store offers greeting cards, jewelry, toys, and home goods, making it easy to find something unique or practical. The layout is welcoming and easy to browse without feeling crowded.

The shop’s commitment to the environment and community stands out. It’s clear they value sustainability and local partnerships, which adds meaning to your purchase. I appreciated how they foster stewardship of Cape May’s natural beauty through their business practices.

The staff were friendly and knowledgeable when I visited. They seemed genuinely invested in the community and the products they offer. If you want something special tied to the local culture or a thoughtful gift, this place is worth a stop.

Rating: 4.8 (115 reviews)
Location: 312 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-4808
Website: Visit Website

3) Across the Way

I found Across the Way to be a charming gift shop with a well-curated selection. The store offers a variety of unique items, from jewelry to cards and toys. It’s easy to browse because the layout is simple and inviting.

One thing that stood out to me was the variety of gifts for cat lovers. That focus added an unexpected but enjoyable twist to the shopping experience. The staff were friendly and helpful, making it easy to find something special.

Price points felt reasonable for the quality and uniqueness of the products. I noticed many repeat visitors stop by during my time there, which says a lot about the store’s reputation. Whether you’re looking for a keepsake or just browsing, this shop has something interesting to offer.

Rating: 4.8 (59 reviews)
Location: 313 Washington St, Cape May, NJ
Contact: (609) 884-4199
Website: Visit Website

4) Good Scents

I found Good Scents to be a charming gift shop with a wide range of items that reflect Cape May’s unique vibe. Walking in, I noticed the carefully chosen products, from scented candles to small home decor pieces, all laid out in a way that invites browsing.

The staff was friendly and helpful, making it easy to ask about specific items or get recommendations. The place feels local and inviting, not overcrowded or overly commercialized, which made my visit pleasant.

Good Scents stands out for its balance between quality and variety. Whether you’re looking for a thoughtful souvenir or something to brighten your home, this shop offers a solid selection at reasonable prices.

Rating: 4.7 (93 reviews)
Location: 327 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-0014
Website: Visit Website

5) Import Bazaar

When I visited Import Bazaar, I was struck by its unique focus on discounted house flags. The shop has a straightforward selection, ideal if you’re looking for affordable and themed flags to decorate your home or give as gifts.

The staff was helpful, and I appreciated that they offer a convenient option to pick up purchases in-store, avoiding shipping fees. Their shipping policy is clear: low flat-rate shipping within the USA, which makes buying in bulk easy and cost-effective.

The location is easy to find on Washington Street in Cape May, and the shop has a friendly atmosphere. It’s not a large or flashy place, but it carries items you won’t easily find elsewhere, especially for flag enthusiasts or those seeking budget-friendly souvenirs.

Rating: 4.9 (31 reviews)
Location: 306 Washington St, Cape May, NJ
Contact: (609) 884-4999
Website: Visit Website

What Makes Cape May Gift Shops Unique?

Cape May’s gift shops stand out because they blend local creativity with rich historical influences. You’ll find items that reflect the coastal lifestyle alongside pieces inspired by the town’s Victorian heritage. This combination creates a shopping experience that is both distinctive and meaningful.

Local Artisans and Crafts

Many shops in Cape May feature products made by local artisans. This includes handcrafted jewelry, pottery, and home decor that you won’t find anywhere else. Stores like Givens Circle specialize in celebrating the artistry of Cape May through carefully selected items.

I’ve noticed the variety ranges from beach-themed accessories to unique, handmade souvenirs. Supporting these artisans helps keep the local creative economy alive and provides visitors with authentic, one-of-a-kind gifts.

Historical Influence on Gifts

Cape May’s history as a Victorian resort town heavily influences its gift shops. You can find vintage-style items and antiques that echo the town’s architectural charm and cultural past. Shops often curate collections that reflect this period, giving gifts a sense of story and place.

In addition to Victorian-inspired products, some stores offer antiques and collectibles that provide a direct link to Cape May’s history. This focus adds depth to the shopping experience, appealing to those interested in heritage as well as unique keepsakes.

Tips for Shopping in Cape May

Shopping in Cape May takes some planning to enjoy the best experience. Timing your visit right and choosing where to spend can make a big difference, especially when looking for unique, locally made gifts.

Best Times to Visit

I recommend visiting Cape May during the spring or fall. The crowds are lighter compared to summer, making it easier to browse without feeling rushed. Many shops open around 10 AM and close by early evening, so arriving mid-morning gives you the full day.

Weekdays are quieter than weekends, especially at popular spots like Washington Street Mall. During off-season months like October and April, you’ll often find seasonal sales and special events. These offer better deals and a more relaxed atmosphere to explore gifts and souvenirs.

Supporting Small Businesses

I always try to support small, local shops when in Cape May because many carry handcrafted and one-of-a-kind items you won’t find anywhere else. These shops contribute directly to the community and keep the town’s charm alive.

When shopping, look for stores specializing in Cape May-themed goods, artisan jewelry, and local food products like olive oil. Asking shop owners about their products can lead to discovering hidden gems and learning the story behind your purchase. This makes the shopping experience more meaningful and impactful for both you and the business.